2011 AFC North NFL Draft Grades
Baltimore Ravens
Baltimore is in a difficult spot as a franchise and this year’s draft was pivotal. The Ravens’ have elite talent on offense for the first time in a while, but they lacked one weapon last year, a deep threat. Anquan Boldin was a great acquisition for the Ravens offense, but without a speedy vertical threat on the outside to stretch the field and a draw safety help over the top, he was just being double covered and prevented from impacting the game the way they had hoped. Torrey Smith was drafted in the 2nd round to be that weapon and at 6’1’’ 204 lbs he is explosive enough to get the job done as well as contribute in the return game. In round 1, Jimmy Smith was drafted to join the Ravens’ experienced and veteran-led defense. He will have ample time to perfect his craft with players like Ray Lewis and Ed Reed to show him the ropes as well as being talented enough to start contributing immediately. Baltimore made significant improvements, but the entire success of this draft is up to whether or not Torrey Smith or Tandon Doss (another speedy WR taken in round 4) is able to stretch the field and give the offense the vertical threat it needs to be both well-balanced and explosive.
My Grade: B+
Cincinnati Bengals
Of all the teams that drafted a QB in this year’s draft, Cincinnati got the best deal of them all. Andy Dalton is from a spread style offense, but seems to have all the off-the-field intangibles that you want from a future franchise QB. In the first round the Bengals also grabbed the top WR in this year’s draft. AJ Green is a very polished receiver that seems a sure thing to be success at the NFL level, but I do not think the Bengals made the right decision here. The season before last, the Bengals were a run-first offense that gave roughly 30 carries per game to Cedric Benson. In that season, they won the division and swept all three divisional opponents. This is no small feat considering that Pittsburgh and Baltimore are in the division. After that, they picked up Terrell Owens off free agency, prioritized the passing game and finished 4-12… behind the Cleveland Browns who went through three different starting QBs over the course of the season. To me, it’s a no-brainer… run the ball. I would have liked to see the Bengals trade the pick away (something tells me Atlanta was willing to pay a ton to trade up and take a WR) and draft an in interior offensive lineman to improve their running game.
My Grade: B-
Cleveland Browns
The Browns were one of the bigger winners in this year’s draft. Their biggest need was a receiver for Colt McCoy to develop along side, but that was far from their only area of concern. Cleveland had a chance for one of the premier receivers in this year’s draft but made the smart choice to trade the pick away to Atlanta. In the trade they acquired first, second and fourth round picks in this draft as well as a first and fourth round pick in next year’s draft. So, despite missing out on an elite talent at their biggest position of need, the Browns enabled themselves to rebuild as a franchise quicker and more effectively. With their first round selection, the Browns took Phil Taylor to anchor the center of their defensive line while they transition to a 4-3 scheme. Taylor is 6’3’’ and 334 lbs. and should make a good replacement for Shaun Rogers. I would have thought Taylor would have been used more as a traditional NT, but he will certainly still be an effective run-stopper in his new 4-3 scheme. The Browns also had two picks in the 2nd round and with the first they added an outside pass rusher to their d-line with Jabaal Sheard. I expect him to start as the right defensive end immediately and be an impact player for quite some time. The second pick of round two was the playmaking WR that they needed most of all. They took 6’3’’ 220 lb. Greg Little. Little showed flashes of big-time playmaking ability in his time at UNC, but was suspended for his final season. This makes him a bit of a risk, but with risk comes the potential for great reward. Little has the skill set to potentially be the best receiver taken in this year’s draft, even if the smart money is on AJ Green.
My Grade: A
Pittsburgh Steelers
I am hesitant to criticize a team that historically drafts phenomenally, but I am going to do it anyway. I thought the Steelers should have drafted a defensive back early and with Aaron Williams still on the board, I really thought they would jump at the chance to take him. Instead they took themselves a new defensive end to join the rotation of pass rushers that terrorizes opposing quarterbacks. Cam Heyward is a 6’5’’ 294 lb monster to play in the five-technique and should flourish in this system, but they just needed someone to play cornerback much more and Williams slid much farther than I thought he would, because Prince Amukamara fell past both Houston and Detroit. Again, in round two, the cornerback position remains unaddressed as they take Marcus Gilbert (6’6’’ 330 lbs.) who I actually like quite a bit as a developmental player. Gilbert may end up being thrown into a starting right tackle role next season because of his size and mobility, but it will take a couple seasons before he can play on the left side, against all the best pass rushers the league has to offer. In rounds three and four the Steelers take a pair of defensive backs that will compete for time in nickel and dime formations, with Curtis Brown (6’0’’ 185lbs.) and Cortez Allen (6’1’’ 248 lbs.). Brown is the more athletic of the two and the better for Pittsburgh’s zone scheme, he has the most potential to be a playmaker in the secondary and we should see him on the field much more than Allen. Time will certainly show that the Steelers got quality players in this draft, but I just can’t help but feel like they need more talented players in the defensive backfield with Troy Polamalu.
My Grade: B-







































